Evaluation Criteria |
Scholarly, Academic, Peer Reviewed Journals |
Trade, Technical Publications |
Popular Magazines |
|
 |
 |
 |
Examples |
American Journal of Sociology
JAMA
Journal of Poplar Culture
Environmental Ethics
|
EMS World
Community College Journal
Science News
Ceramics Monthly
|
Time
Consumer Reports
Rolling Stone
GQ
|
Content |
Original Research
Research results
Reviews of research
Book reviews
|
Industry/Profession related articles
News
Products
Trends
|
Current Events
General Interest
Special Interest
|
Purpose |
Share results of original research with academic community |
Inform on profession news, trends, and products
Practical advice for professionals
|
Provides news, entertainment, sell products |
Audience |
Scholars
Researchers
Students
|
Industry professionals |
General Public
Nonprofessionals
|
Authorship |
Expert in the field
Credentials are identified
|
Professional in the field
Staff writer with subject expertise
|
Journalists
Freelancers
Staff Writers
|
Review Process |
Evaluated by experts in the field
Peer reviewed
|
Staff editor or industry professional |
Staff Editor |
Cites Sources |
Research is documented by:
Bibliographies / Works Cited
Footnotes
References
Endnotes
|
Few to none |
None
May refer to other studies
|
Article Format |
Articles typically contain:
Abstract (Summary)
Introduction
Literature Review
Methodology
Results
Discussion
Conclusion
Bibliography / Reference List
|
Articles may contain:
Short reference list
|
No specific format |
Appearance |
Few to no ads
Lengthy Articles
Tables and graphs of data that support text
Mostly black and white
|
Industry specific ads
Color photos
|
Shorter articles
Advertisements
Color photos
|
Publisher |
Scholarly Publishers
University Press
Professional Association
|
Professional Associations
Industry related commercial groups
|
Commercial group
Media conglomerate
|